Let’s face it: most guys screw up their first threesome.
Not because they’re bad people.
Because they’re either:
If you want your threesome to be memorable—in a good way—avoid these nine mistakes that most men make (often in spectacular fashion).
You zero in on the new girl… and your partner goes emotionally cold.
Fix it:
Divide your attention intentionally. Make eye contact with both. Invite your partner into everything. Include, don’t isolate.
You assume “everything goes,” and someone ends up in tears—or furious.
Fix it:
Before anything starts, ask:
In the heat of the moment, you scramble for a condom, drop it, or worse—forget entirely.
Fix it:
Have multiple condoms and lube in arm’s reach. No fumbles. No excuses.
Liquid courage becomes sloppy execution.
Fix it:
Keep it light. One drink max. Be fully present and in control of your body and words.
You treat her like a prop instead of a person.
She gets uncomfortable. She ghosts. Your partner feels icky.
Fix it:
Engage emotionally. Smile. Check in. Thank her.
Respect is sexy.
You try to choreograph the whole thing like it’s a stage play.
Fix it:
Let things unfold naturally. Stay open to cues from both women. Go with the vibe—not your mental script.
You pretend nothing happened and scroll your phone like it’s Sunday night football.
Fix it:
Ask:
“How did that feel for you?”
“Anything we should talk about?”
“Would you do it again?”
This is where the trust is built.
You think this is the beginning of your new “threesome lifestyle.” She thinks it was a one-time thing.
Fix it:
Don’t assume. Ask.
Let the experience stand on its own. Let her come back to it if she wants.
You start fantasizing. Texting. Wondering “what if.”
Fix it:
Set emotional boundaries. Stay anchored to your partner. Keep the third a guest—not a new romantic lead.
A good threesome isn’t about being the best in bed—it’s about being the best communicator, connector, and collaborator.
Avoid these rookie mistakes and you won’t just have a threesome…
You’ll have a story worth telling (without cringing).
➤ I've been coaching men since 2011 and have approached thousands of women myself. I can teach you the art of social mastery and confidence building. Contact me directly for a free consultation about private coaching.